Hold Me Tight is an original track, written by Paul McCartney and appearing on With The Beatles.
The Beatles BibleAlthough released on their second album With The Beatles, ‘Hold Me Tight’ was originally attempted by The Beatles during the mammoth 11 February 1963 session that yielded the bulk of songs for Please Please Me.
Continue reading on Beatles Bible →
WikipediaI don’t think it’s a coincidence that Hold Me Tight is one of a trilogy of “hold” songs all completed between September and October of 1963. The Smokey Robinson cover You Really Got A Hold On Me is another track from With The Beatles, and of course the Beatles US breakthrough single was I Want To Hold Your Hand.
“Hold” is a very useful verb for a pop song. It definitely says physical contact, but it can suggest something chaste and protective, more passionate or even outright sexual depending on how you read it. Perfect for a song that seems intended to resonate with the band’s swooning fans, many of whom would have liked nothing better than to hold one or more of the Beatles tight.
That was Paul’s. Maybe I stuck some bits in there – I don’t remember. It was a pretty poor song and I was never really interested in it either way. (John Lennon)
‘Hold Me Tight’ was a failed attempt at a single which then became an acceptable album filler. Certain songs were just ‘work’ songs, you haven’t got much memory of them. That’s one of them. (Paul McCartney)
Both Lennon and McCartney were rather dismissive of Hold Me Tight, which is a shame as it is a very nicely crafted pop song. It’s excellent and I really can’t agree. To me the verses with their call and response vocal arrangement are influenced by the New York girl groups, but there’s at least a dash of Motown and old school rock’n’roll (the guitar riff). The “it’s you” section is very McCartneyesque, with its “you, you, you” recalling PS I Love You and bringing a touch of musical theatre and a hint of Roy Orbison. The bridge turns up the tension as the volume comes down, the hi-hats drop out and the toms take over. There’s nothing trivial or formulaic about the song; it’s a real original.
Granted, it has some mixed reputation among even the serious fans, and none other than Paul himself has been known to vaguely shrug it off as just a “work song”. But, no matter, there is no escaping its technical sophistication. (Alan W Pollack)
This type of track, catchy, energetic and musically inventive is really what set the Beatles apart from other bands in the early sixties. They had strength in depth – whether finding a place on the live setlist or on an album each song had to earn its place. A McCartney or Lennon original outcompete the covers they selected carefully from all the rock’n’roll oldies they knew from their Hamburg days and the dozens of new tracks they listened to in Brian Epstein’s NEMS shop. Each writer had to convince first their songwriting partner and then the other bandmates, all of whom were discerning and critical.
Having overcome those hurdles the Hold Me Tight got the Beatles treatment, and even if they considered it a “work” song, the arrangement and performance stand up very well in the context of the album. People point out a few little fluffs in the vocal (they sing clashing vocals on the last syllable of “It feels so right, so/now”), so maybe it didn’t quite get the attention to detail that some of their recordings had. The current ranking (with all its shortcomings) places it second among the originals (there are some excellent covers on the album), and I think you could make the case that it is the best. Lennon and McCartney seem to have considered it a failed single, but I reckon it would have been a hit. I admit that I don’t know McCartney’s solo work anywhere near as well as I know the Beatles catalogue, but it’s my impression that he has rarely recorded as good a pop song as Hold Me Tight since the Beatles split.